The Lord of the Rings: The Two Towers Gave Us Cinema’s Best Fantasy Battle, Helm’s Deep, 20 Years In the past

The Lord of the Rings: The Two Towers Gave Us Cinema’s Best Fantasy Battle, Helm’s Deep, 20 Years In the past

Not often is the center installment in a movie trilogy the entry that any fandom would coalesce round and advance as that trilogy’s most interesting second. The Empire Strikes Again is way more exception than rule on this respect, and center installments generally tend to undergo in retrospective evaluation, missing the wondrous introduction to a cinematic world provided by the primary entry, or the catharsis of closure present in a trilogy ender. Too typically, these follow-ups really feel extra akin to connective materials, bridging the hole between a memorable introduction and epic conclusion.

And but, in case you polled movie followers about the most effective pure entry in Peter Jackson’s iconic Lord of the Rings trilogy, I wouldn’t be in any respect stunned if center film The Two Towers managed to edge out The Fellowship of the Ring for the crown, with The Return of the King ending a distant (and deserved) third. That second entry, launched 20 years in the past this weekend, can’t lay declare to the guts and heat of Fellowship, or the size and stakes of Return of the King. However what it can boast is the most effective rattling fantasy battle in cinema historical past, and some of the satisfying incarnations of Tolkien’s story, within the type of Helm’s Deep. With that enormous set piece as its anchor, The Two Towers each honors its supply materials and supplies an exciting siege that few different movies have managed to even strategy within the final twenty years.

Granted, we have been exceedingly fortunate to ever have an opportunity to see such a spectacle dropped at life within the first place, a subject we’ve written about earlier than at appreciable size. Peter Jackson’s movie trilogy was a deeply unlikely film miracle, one which happened with precisely the best folks, at precisely the best time, because the keys to probably the most well-known fantasy fiction IP in historical past have been improbably handed off to a comparatively untested New Zealand director greatest recognized for splatter horror motion pictures. The visuals seen at Helm’s Deep, in the meantime, couldn’t have been rendered only some years earlier, with groundbreaking results work (particularly in massive crowds of CGI orcs) from Weta Workshop that set a brand new commonplace for large-scale motion scenes. And lord solely is aware of what Jackson’s LOTR might need seemed like if it had been caught in improvement hell for just a few extra years, arriving after Spider-Man had extra totally established the mould of the fashionable superhero movie, and in flip the fashionable blockbuster franchise. The director’s personal Hobbit trilogy from just a few years later provides an unnerving glimpse of how simply this venture may have been sabotaged by studio meddling.

We must always by no means cease being grateful, then, that The Lord of the Rings arrived when it did, and that Jackson was given free rein to venture the somber, dignified, noble however despairing vitality that makes The Two Towers stand out so starkly. That is the movie within the collection with an ethos most succinctly summed up with a single phrase that characters are at all times repeating (it’s “hope”), however there’s additionally much more to it than that. The movie captures the concern in Tolkien’s personal coronary heart of a way of grandeur, magic, the Aristocracy and compassion slipping away from the world, of crumbling societies forgetting and discarding the rules that after made them nice in favor of chilly, impassive modernism. We meet Theoden, King of Rohan because the final, pale remnant of a line of males who have been wiser, stronger, extra valiant and enduring than he has confirmed to be, and we watch him be pulled again from the brink with the help of his new allies. However nonetheless, the true battle unfolds in his coronary heart, between conviction and utter despair on the considered his folks being wiped away without end by forces past his management. Because the heartbroken man calls for to know in his lowest second: “What can males do in opposition to such reckless hate?”

Naturally, there may be some revisionism inserted into the Helm’s Deep battle within the translation from Tolkien’s web page to the screenplay by Fran Walsh, Philippa Boyens, Stephen Sinclair and Jackson. The contingent of elves from Lothlorien arriving earlier than the battle to lend support wasn’t a side included by Tolkien, however it works nicely as a symbolic step within the general collection theme of reforging historic alliances which were allowed to atrophy and decay over the course of centuries—a step in Aragorn’s progress as a would-be uniter who can reforge these previous bonds, a lot because the sword of the king is finally reforged. Likewise, the movie portrays the numbers within the battle to be significantly extra one-sided than in Tolkien’s novel, as a way to exemplify the underdog standing of Theoden and his folks. Once more, an comprehensible change from a cinematic perspective, one which heightens the drama of Theoden and Aragorn’s eventual determination to “experience out and meet them,” because the viewers is aware of simply how futile this closing cost is prone to be.


So too does Jackson discover little methods to protect sure, integral facets of Tolkien’s general philosophy towards these characters, resembling resisting the temptation to jot down Gandalf a extra pivotal and direct function within the battle. That is becoming, on condition that not often if ever does Tolkien permit the characters in his story who’re implicitly imbued with probably the most energy—Gandalf, Galadriel, Elrond, and many others.—to bodily step in and exhibit the depths of their energy, outdoors of feats described within the appendices. Gandalf’s energy, in each the books and the movies, isn’t expressed via martial prowess or blasts of lightning from his fingers, placing the enemy useless the place they stand. Quite, his present is the power to imbue compassion and encourage bravery and valor within the on a regular basis folks round him, be they hobbits or doughty warriors of Rohan. The wizard doesn’t win the battle along with his late arrival; he merely brings these folks—Theoden, Aragorn, Eomer and his riders—collectively so they can win the battle, and in doing so, fill themselves with the resolve to win not simply the battle, however the struggle. And that’s The Lord of the Rings at coronary heart; not a narrative about superpowered, battling heroes, however a narrative in regards to the conscientious contributions made by small, particular person gamers that transform momentous ultimately.

Make no mistake, although, the Battle of Helm’s Deep pales compared to the sheer scale and epic breadth of Return of the King’s Battle of the Pelennor Fields, which unfolds earlier than the gates of Minas Tirith. However I might argue—and I count on no small variety of LOTR geeks would agree—that Helm’s Deep is finally extra satisfying, as a result of it feels considerably extra grounded within the bodily, grinding battle of our weary protagonists as they throw wave after wave of Uruk-hai again from the partitions. The grand battle of Return of the King can’t assist however give up itself extra to CGI-driven spectacle, particularly as soon as the large struggle beasts get entangled, with these digital photographs serving to carry our heroes no less than barely at arm’s size from actually feeling like they’re interacting within the battle. At Helm’s Deep, however, the mud, rain and grit seeps into each pore. It initiatives a way more determined, vicious really feel, a combat to purchase further minutes and seconds to stave off the inevitable. As Theoden leaves his publish on the wall commanding the battle to take up a spear and bodily confront the enemy on the splintering gate, it’s clear how excessive the stakes have turn out to be.


It’s a battle with gravitas, a doomed final stand remodeled in opposition to hope to miraculous victory, and a cinematic expertise I’ll always remember. I can nonetheless bear in mind, the truth is, the precise second of rapture I skilled as a 16-year-old Tolkien geek, as Theoden started intoning his “the place is the horse and the rider?” poem. “I can’t imagine this made it into the film,” I marveled. “I can’t imagine I’m truly watching any of this on the massive display.”

Twenty years later, it nonetheless appears simply as outstanding that Jackson pulled it off.

Jim Vorel is a Paste employees author and resident style geek. You may follow him on Twitter for extra movie writing.

Leave a Reply